Wednesday, February 8, 2012

Computer Assisted Language Learning (CALL)




Name -            Bhatt Dhara J
Roll no:  -        2
M.A.Part-2 -   Sem-4
Paper -             02, Ec-402
Paper name - English teaching
Language- 2
Topic for Assignment    - Computer Assisted Language Learning (CALL)
Submitted To: Dr.Dilipsir Barad
  Department of English,
  Bhavnagar university,
  Bhavnagar.                 
Computer Assisted Language Learning (CALL)
                  
v Introduction
          In the second half of the 20th century, education technologies were one of the most developed areas in the world. Computers, which have entered the school life in the late 1950s in developed countries, are still developing day by day throughout the world. Today, they have become more powerful, faster, easier to use, more convenient and cheaper, and they can process and store much more data, as well. Equipment such as hard disks, CD­ROMs, laser disks and printers used with computers has also developed rapidly. Using these, a computer program can handle sound, pictures and video along with characters.
          At the end of the 20th century; the computer-mediated' communication and the Internet have reshaped the use of computers for language learning. Computers are no longer a tool for only information processing and display but also a tool for information processing and communication. Learners of language, with the help of the Internet, can now simultaneously communicate with others or speakers of the target language all over the world. Nonetheless, As Dhaif (1989) claims computers can never replace the 'live' teacher, especially in language teaching, where the emphasis is on mutual communication between people. It can just play a role in teaching the second or foreign language as an aid to the teacher.
          Today, there is huge amount of foreign language materials next to the traditional grammar book and dictionary. These materials include-course books, workbooks, programmed courses, cue carts, charts, newspapers, posters, picture cards, and cut outs, and so on. These are supplemented by other media, such as radio, television, slides, OHP, video tapes, games, toys, realia, as well as computers, multi media and the Internet.
          The language laboratories which were found in the 1970s under the influence of the Audio-lingual Method have given room to computer assisted language learning (CALL) work stations. "Micro computers used as word processors complement the audio facilities, enabling the interactive teaching of all four language skills reading, listening, speaking and writing". (Crystal, 1987: 377). Crystal further adds that today a great variety of FLT exercises, such as sentence restructuring, checking of spelling, checking of translations, or dictation tasks, and cloze tests can be computationally controlled" using texts displayed on the screen.

          Recent years have shown a boom of interest in using computers for foreign language teaching and learning. A decade ago, the use of computers in the language classroom was of concern only to a small number of specialists in western countries. However, with the advent of multimedia computing and the Internet, the role of computers in language instruction has now become an important issue confronting large numbers of language teachers throughout the world.
          To be realistic, although most teachers throughout the world still use chalk and blackboard, CALL is used routinely in language instruction in highly developed countries, such as the USA, Japan, and Western European countries including Turkey to provide supplementary practice in the four skills writing, reading, speaking and listening, as well as grammar and problem solving. Though, as Chappell points, "instructors need to understand how CALL can best be used to offer effective instruction to language learners" (1990: 199).

v The Computer
          Computer is a device that processes information with great speed and accuracy. Computers process information by helping to create the information itself, by displaying, storing, recognizing, and communicating information to other computers. In general they process numbers, words, still or moving pictures, and sounds.
          The computer has changed the way people work, learn, communicate, and play. It is used by students, teachers, and research scientists as a learning tool all over the world, as well as by individuals at home to study, work and entertain.
          In Encarta Encyclopedia (2000) it is recorded that the first electronic digital computer was developed by the Hungarian-American mathematician John von Neumann to solve problems in mathematics, meteorology, economics, and hydrodynamics. Then, the American physicist John Mauchly proposed the electronic digital computer called ENIAC and build it with the American engineer J. Presper Eckert at the University of Pennsylvania in Philadelphia. ENIAC which is completed in 1945 is regarded as the first successful, general digital computer. However, it weighed more than 27,000 kg and contained more than 18,000 vacuum tubes. The computer's vacuum tubes were replaced by a team of six technicians each month and it had to be reprogrammed for each task. ENIAC initially was used for military purposes. Fortunately, the technology of computer hardware, the physical parts of computer systems, has advanced tremendously since then. Today a single microprocessor of approximately 2 kg can do the same work as that pioneering machine (Snyder: 2000, in Encarta Encyclopedia).
         On the other hand, the programs that run the computer are called Software. Software, is the set of instructions a computer uses to manipulate data, such as a word­ processing, (e.g., to write a letter), program or a video game. These programs are usually stored and transferred via the computer's hardware to and from the CPU. The interaction between the input and output hardware is controlled by software called the Basic Input Output System software (BIOS). Software programs are loaded on either disks or CD­ROMs (compact discs). There is a big variety of readymade language learning software in the market today. Some of these are WIDA; Oxford advanced Leaner's Dictionary on CD­ROM, Learn to Speak English, Encarta Encyclopedia and many more.

ð What is the Role of the Computer in Teaching?
          The computer is a human made tool which is incapable of action. That is, it has no inborn wisdom, no initiative and inherent ability to learn or to teach. It will perform, with remarkable speed, the instructions exactly given to it by a human user. Thus, the computer is 'the servant of the user' and it should not be forgotten that its role in teaching is solely a teaching aid. Consequently, it is dependent on the teacher in many ways: for example, it is unable to create educational materials without the teacher. All the linguistic material and instructions for its presentation must be specified by the teacher. It is the teacher who decides what degree of control the computer will have in her/his classes. Hence, as Brierley & Kemble (1991) state there is no need for teachers to feel threatened to lose their professions to the computer.
          The computer can be situated. in the classroom, in a special laboratory (CALL, laboratory), in a specially designed area of a library or in any convenient location where the student, or small groups of students can work uninterruptedly (Ahmed, Corbett, Rogers & Sussex: 1985). It can be used as the mainstay of a course, or back up, revision, reinforcement, extension, and so on. It may communicate with the student visually by displaying text, graphics or video images on a screen; it can also present sound in the form of speech, music or other audio-output. The most common means of communication with the computer is by clicking on icons with the mouse or by typing commands and responses at a keyboard (Higgins: 1995). As a result, unique combinations of interactive and visual capabilities, computers have a beneficial effect on learner motivation.
v Computer Assisted and Language Learning (CALL)
          The abbreviation CALL stands for Computer Assisted Language Learning. It is a term used by teachers and students to describe the use of computers as part of a language course. (Hardisty & Windeatt: 1989). It is traditionally described as a means of 'presenting, reinforcing and testing' particular language items. The learner is first presented with a rule and some examples, and then answers a series of questions which test her/his knowledge of the rule and the computer gives appropriate feedback and awards a mark, which may be stored for later inspection for the teacher. Jones & Fortescue (1987) indicate that the traditional description of CALL is unfortunate and they present the computer as flexible classroom aid, which can be used by teachers and learners, in and out of class, in a variety of ways and for a variety of purposes. However, work with the computer, as any other teaching aid, needs to be linked with ordinary classroom work and CALL lessons, like the other lessons, need to be planned carefully.
.'\

v The History of CALL
          Although computers have been used since the first half of the 20th century, they were not used for educational purposes until the 1960s. The 1970s witnessed the evolution of CALL as a result of development in research related to the use of computers for linguistic purposes and for creating suitable language learning conditions. In America the computer based introductory courses in the 1960s were pioneering projects in CALL, and were referred to as computer Assisted Instruction (CAl) The 1980s have witnessed the spread of computers both in educational institutions and in people's homes. Since the beginning of the '80s computers have also found their way into many schools. CALL software has also become more readily available on the market (Ittelson: 2000).

          The emergence of inexpensive computer technology and mass storage media, including optical videodiscs and compact disks, has given instructional technologists better tools to work with. Compact disks are used to store large amounts of data, such as encyclopedias or motion pictures. In CALL centers with computers and software such as CD-ROM, CD-I, or videodiscs, a student who is interested in a particular topic can first scan an electronic encyclopedia, then view a film on the subject or look at related topics at the reach of a button. Thus, such learning centers present students with the advantages of reference materials and popularize computer-aided instruction. The computer laboratory has become an integral component of foreign-language programs in most educational institutions (Hardisty & Windeatt: 1989).
          Computers have been used for language teaching for more than three decades. According to Warschauer & Healey (1998) the history of CALL can be divided into three stages: behaviouristic CALL, communicative CALL and integrative CALL.
          Each stage corresponds to a certain pedagogical approach.
ð Behaviouristic CALL
          It was formed in the late 1960s and used widely in the 1970s under the influence of Audio-lingual teaching method. In this stage of CALL, repetitive language drills, referred to as drill-and practice were used. The computer was seen as a mechanical tutor who never allowed students to work at an individual pace, which hindered motivation. Further, it included extensive drills, grammatical explanations and translation at various intervals (Warschauer & Healey 1998).
ð Communicative CALL
          It was the period of the 1980s. This period was the time that behaviouristic approach to language teaching was being rejected at both theoretical and pedagogical level, and also personal computers were creating greater possibilities for individual work at school. Communicative CALL corresponded to cognitive theories which stressed that learning was a process of discovery, expression and development. Under the influence of Communicative Language Teaching defendants of communicative CALL argued that computer based activities should focus more on using forms. Software developed in this period included text reconstruction program and simulations. In communicative CALL, the focus was not so much on what students did with the computer, but rather what they did with each other while working at the computer.

ð Interactive CALL
          By the 1990s communicative CALL began to be criticized. New second language acquisition theories and socio-cognitive views influenced many teachers and lead them to use more social and learner-centered methods. This time, emphasis was put on language use in authentic social contexts. Task-based, project-based and content-based approaches all sought to integrate learners in authentic environments, and also to integrate the various skills of language learning and use. In integrative approaches, students are enabled to use a variety of technological tools as an ongoing process of language learning and use rather than visiting the computer lab once a week basis for isolated exercises.
v Fluency and accuracy practice
          One of the characteristics of many CALL programs is that the students have to pronounce or type in exactly the answer the computer expects because the computer can only accept the answers it has been programmed to accept. This limitation is very useful in practice because it provides motivation for the students to use the language as accurately as possible.
v Computer-work, pre-computer work and post-computer work
There are three stages in CALL activities:
a)       Pre-computer work before students make use of the machines;
b)      Work done at the computer;
c )      Post-computer work done away from the computer (Hardisty and Windeatt: 1989).

v CALL AND LANGUAGE SKILLS
          Computers offer learners various activities for developing different language skills. They can provide a useful and motivating medium for both integrated skills and separate activities. Warschauer & Healey (1998) describe them as follows:

ð Reading Skills
          There are three main ways in which computers are useful in helping language learners develop reading skills.
a)       Incidental reading. Most of the CALL programs, whether oriented towards reading or not, involve the learner in reading text for the successful completion of the activity.
b)      Reading comprehension. Traditional question and answer CALL programs are used for reading comprehension as well as grammar and vocabulary development.
c)       Text manipulation. There are a number of ways in which computers can manipulate continuous text which involve the learner in close study of the content and structure of the text. An example might be shadow reading which provides students with authentic texts. Additionally, sentence structure, speed reading and cloze-reading are some of the alternative ways of developing reading skills. An example for software matching activity might be the JMS Newline activity: 'Match the slang words with their definitions'. Another activity might be JMS Newline Software: Speed Practice Reading Comprehension activity (Sperling, 1998).

ð Writing Skills
          The Word Processing program is one of the most common purposes for which computers are used and it is regarded as the most powerful to use when starting to work with CALL. In order to use word processors learners have to be familiar to the keyboard of the computer and they also have to learn the following before using the computer:
·        Learn how to start a word processor
·        Learn how to delete and insert a letter, a word or a larger chunk of text
·        Learn how to save text
·        Print a text
·        Moving words, lines, sentences, etc. around.
          Word-processing programs transform the computer into a sophisticated and flexible writing aid that can improve learners' writing skills and their attitude toward writing. The main principle of word-processing programs is based on the ability to manipulate text freely. By writing text into the memory of a computer, the writer can play round with his text until entirely satisfied. The word-processor provides useful practice for guided and free writing.
          Vocabulary, grammar, punctuation and reading tests have an obvious relevance to the sub-skills that are needed for writing (Duber: 2000). By providing something to write about, the computer stimulates both writing and speaking. An example might be the following activity from the Redhouse Dictionary CD-ROM: 'Put the jumbled idioms in order and write them in your notebook'.
ð Speaking Skills
          Oral communication is very important in language learning process. In today's language "classrooms, considerable emphasis is given to oral activities in which learners use the language they have learned to communicate with each other. These activities include simulations, role-plays and discussion. Computer simulations provide a stimulus for such a work, as they offer both a focus for oral activity and a continually changing scenario for learners to talk about. Computers have a useful contribution to the development of oral skills if they are used wisely (Hammersmith: 1998).
          Dialogue studies can be made by the computers with the aid of the movies; students watching these dialogues can see the conversation, setting and cultural atmosphere clearly. They can also see the body movements and the semiotic background of the conversations and earn a powerful experience and thus improve their communicative competence. These all pave the way to their communicative performances through reinforcing their accuracy, intelligibility and fluency.
          The main advantage of computer simulations is that they are very motivating. They give learners instant feedback on the effects of their decisions, and this feedback itself stimulates arguments and comments, suggestions and counter suggestions. An activity for improving listening and speaking skills might be a listening activity from 'Learn to Speak English Software I': Spoken English Demo: Communication Skills.
                                                                                
ð Listening Skills
        Listening activities that use the computer are more complex than the other kinds of  CALL materials since they involve equipment other than the computer itself. One of the simplest ways of giving practice in listening comprehension is to use a multiple-choice or fill-in program in conjunction with a cassette recorder or the latest multimedia containing a recorder. In addition to the normal feedback given after a wrong answer, the computer can let the learner hear the relevant part of the tape again. If a separate cassette recorder is used, the error message can give the learner appropriate counter numbers. Another simple technique is to use a tape with a test-reconstruction program which enables learners to reconstruct a summary of a recorded anecdote on screen by the help of the tape.
          Such activities not only help to integrate listening and writing skills but also evaluate learners' listening comprehension skills in a more active way than is generally possible in a non-CALL class (Jones & Fortescue: 1987). An activity for improving listening skills might be a listening activity from 'JMS Newline Software', The Listening Leaner: Listening Comprehension, Spoken English.
v Conclusion
The role of computer in language teaching has changed signified in the last three decades previously; computers used in language teaching were limited to text. The computer is a mechanical device which can be used well or badly. The use of computers is compatible with a variety of approaches, methods and techniques of learning and teaching.

Wednesday, November 23, 2011

An Introduction to Edward Said's Orientalism, EE- 305, Post colonial Literature




Name              -      Bhatt. Dhara. J

Roll no:          -       02

M.A.Part-2    -       Sem-3

Paper                      5, E-E-305

Paper name           Post Colonial Literature    

Topic for Assignment      -
An Introduction to Edward Said’s Orientalism

Submitted To: Dr.Dilipsir Barad
  Department of English,
  Bhavnagar university,
  Bhavnagar.                




An introduction to Edward Said’s Orientalism

·      Author - Edward W. Said
·      Publisher- Vintage
·      Year       - 1994

                                               “Orientalism” by Edward Said is Canonical text of cultural studies in which he challenged the Concept of Orientalism or the difference between east and west; as he puts it. He says that with start of European Colonization the Europeans came in contact with lesser developed Countries of the east. They found their civilization and culture very exotic, and established the science of Orientalism, which was the study of the Orientals or the people from these exotic civilizations.

                                  The book by chapter

Chapter - 1
“The Scope of Orientalism”

(1) Knowing the Oriental
(2) Imaginative Geography and its Representation:
     Oriental sings the Oriental.
(3) Projects.
(4) Crisis.

Chapter - 2

“Orientalists   Structures and Restructures”

(1)  Redrawn Frontiers, Redefined issues, Secularized Religion
(2)  Silvestre de Stacy and Ernest Renan: Rational Anthropology and Philological.
(3)  Oriental Residence and Scholarship: The Requirements of Lexicography and
(4)  Pilgrims and Pilgrimages, British and French

Chapter - 3

“Orientalism now”

(1)  Latent and Manifest Orientalism
(2)  Style, Expertise, Vision; Orientalism   World illness
(3)  Modern Anglo: French Orientalism in its fullest Flower
(4)  The Latest phase.

Basic knowledge about the Chapter:

Chapter-1

“The Scope of Orientalism”

                                   In this Section Said outlines his argument with several caveats as to how it may be flawed. He States that it fails to include Russian Orientalism  and explicitly excludes German Orientalism, which he suggests had “clean “ Pasts(Said 1978: 2 and 4),and could be promising future studies. Said also suggests that not all academic discourse in the west has to be orient list in its intent but much of it is. He also suggests that all cultures have a view of other cultures that may be exotic and harmless to some extent, but it is not this view that he argues against and when this view is taken by a military and economically dominant culture against another it can lead to disastrous results.

Chapter-2

                      “Orientalist   Structures and Restructures”

                                          In this chapter Said outlines how Orientalist discourse was transferred from Country to Country and Political leader to author. He suggests that this discourse was set up as a foundation for all further study and discourse of the Orient by the occident.

                                              He States that

                              “The four elements I have described expansion, historical Confrontation, sympathy, classification are the Currents in eighteenth century thought on whose presence the specific intellectual and institutional structures of modern Orientalism depend.”
                                Further travelers and academics of the East depended on this discourse for their own education, and so the Orientalist discourse the West over and East was passed down through European Writers and politician (and therefore through all European)

Chapter - 3

                    “Orientalism Now”

                    This chapter starts off by telling us that how the geography of the world was shaped by the Colonization of the Europeans. There was a quest for geographical knowledge which formed the base of Orientalism.

                     The author then talks about the changing approach to Orientalism in 20th century. The main difference was that where the earlier Orientalist was more of silent observers the new Orientalist took a part in the everyday life of the orients. The earlier oriental lists did not interact a lot with the orients, whereas the new orients lived with them as if they were one of them . This was not out of appreciation of their lifestyle but was to know more about the orients in order to rule them properly. Lawrence of Arabia was one of such Orient lists.

                      Then Edward said goes on to talk about two other Scholars Massignon and Gibb. Though Massignon was a bit liberal with Oriental lists and often tried to protect their rights, there was still inherited biased found him for the Orientals, which can be seen in his work. With the changing world situation especially after World War I, Orientalism took a more liberal stance towards most of its subjects, but Islamic Orientalism did not enjoy this status. There were Constant attacks to show Islam as a weak religion, and a mixture of many religions and thoughts. Gibb was the most famous Islamic Orientalists of this time.               

                          After World War I the centre of Orientalism moved from Europe to USA. One important transformed (transformation) that took place during this time was instance of relating it to Philology and it was related to social science now. All the orientalists study the Orientals to assist their Government to come up with Policies for dealing with the orient Countries. With the end of World War 2, all the Europeans Colonies were lost; and it was believed that there were no more Orientals and Occident, but this was surely not the case. Western prejudice towards eastern Countries was still very explicit, and often they managed to generalize most of the eastern Countries because of it. For example Arabs were often represented as cruel and violent people. Japanese were always considered to be terrorists, thus, this goes on to show that even with increasing globalization and awareness, such bias was found in the people of the developed Countries.

                        Edward Said conclude his book by saying that he is not saying that the Orientalists should not make generalization, or they should include the orient perspective too, but creating a boundary at the first place is something which should not be done.

                        Hereby the presenter has narrowed down her discussion to the first part of the book Orientalism that is scope of Orientalism in study sub-chapter.
Ø Chapter- 1
                      “The Scope of Orientalism”


(1)       Knowing the Oriental


vIntroduction

                          On June 13, 1910, Arthur James Balfour lectured the House of Commons on “the Problems with which we have to deal in Egypt”. Then, he said, “Belong to a wholly different category.” Than those” affecting the Isle of Wight or the west Riding of Yorkshire.”
   
                           During his involvement in imperial affairs Belfour Serve a monarch who in 1876 had been declared Empress of India; he had been especially well placed in position of uncommon influence to follow the Afghan and Zulu wars, the British occupation of Egypt in 1882, the death of General Gordon in the Sudan, the Russo- Japanese war.               

                           Two great themes dominate his remarks here and in what will follow: Knowledge and Power, the Bacon an themes. As Balfour justifies the necessity for British occupation of Egypt, Supremacy in his mind is associated with”our” knowledge of Egypt and not principally with military or economic power. Knowledge to Balfour means rising above immediacy, beyond self, into Foreign and distant. The object of such knowledge in inherently Vulnerable to scrutiny; this object is a “fact” which, it develops, changes or otherwise transforms itself in the way that civilizations frequently do, nevertheless is fundamentally, even ontologically stable.                                                 

Balfour must then go on to the next part of argument:

                             It is a good thing for these great nations – I admire their greatness – that this absolute Government should be exercised by us? I think it is a good thing. I think that experience shows that they have got under it far better government that in the whole history of the world they ever had before, and which not only is a benefit to them, but it undoubtedly a benefit to the whole to the civilized west……. We are Egypt not merely for the sake of the Egyptians/ though we are these for their sake; we are there also for the sake of Europe at large.

                       Balfour produces no evidence that Egyptians and “the races with whom we deal.” Appreciate or even understand the good that is being done them by Colonial occupation. It does not occur to Balfour , however, to let the Egyptian speak for himself , since presumably any Egyptian who would speak out is more likely to be “ the agitator (Who) wishes to raise difficulties” than the good native who overlooks the “difficulties” of foreign domination. 

                               England knows Egypt; Egypt is what England knows: England knows that Egypt cannot have self-government; England confirms that by occupying Egypt; for the Egyptians, Egypt is what England has occupied and now governs; foreign occupation therefore become” the very basic” of Contemporary Egyptian civilization ; Egypt requires, indeed insist upon, British occupation. But is the special intimacy, between governor and governed in Egypt in disturbed by parliament’s doubts at home, then “the authority of what… is the dominant race and as I think ought to remain the dominant race – has been undermined.” Not only does English prestige suffer; “ It is vain for a handful of British officials – endow them how you like, give them all the qualities of character the genius you can imagine – it is impossible for them to carry out the great task which in Egypt, not we only, but the civilized world have imposed upon them.”

Cromer made Egypt, said Balfour:

                              Everything he has touched he has succeeded in … Lord Cromer’s Services during the past quarter of a century have raised Egypt from the lowest pitch of social and economic degradation until   now stands among oriental nation I believe , absolutely alone in its prosperity , financial and moral.

                               How Egypt’s moral prosperity was measured, Balfour did not venture to say. British exports to Egypt equaled those to the whole of Africa; that century indicated a sort of financial prosperity, for Egypt and England (some what) together.

                               How much “Serious Consideration” the ruler ought to give proposals from the subject race was illustrated in Cromer’s total opposition to Egyptian nationalism. Free native institutions, the absence of foreign occupation, a self-sustaining nation sovereignty:” these unsurprising demands were consistently rejected by Comer, who asserted unambiguously that the real future of Egypt …. Lies not in the direction of a narrow nationalism, which will only embrace native ‘Egyptians ….. But rather in that of an enlarged Cosmopolitanisms”.

Sir Alfred Lyall Once Said To Balfour:

                               “Accuracy is abhorrent to the Oriental mind. Every Anglo- Indian should always remember that maxim.” Want of accuracy, which easily degenerates into untruthfulness, is in fact the main characteristic of the Oriental mind.”

                                The European is a close reasoned; his statements of fact are devoid of any ambiguity; he is natural logician, albeit he may  not have studied logical; he is by nature skeptical and requires proof before he can accept the truth of any proposition; his trained intelligence works like a piece of mechanism. Many terms were used to express the relation: Balfour and Cromer, typically, used several.

                         The Oriental is irrational, depraved (fallen), childlike, “different”; Thus the European is rational, virtuous, mature,” normal.” In Cromer’s and Balfour’s language the oriental is depicted as something one judges (as in a Court of law), Something one studies depicts (as in Curriculum), Something one discipline (as in a school or prison), Something one illustrates(as in a Zoological manual).

                          An order of Sovereignty is set up from East to West, a mock chain of being whose clearest from given once by Kipling:

                           Mule, horse, elephant , or bullock, he obey his driver, and the driver his sergeant, and the sergeant his lieutenant, and the lieutenant his captain, and his Captain his major, and major his Colonel, and the Colonel his brigadier Commanding three regiments and the brigadier’s general who obeys the Viceroy, who , is the servant of the Empress.

                            As deeply forged as it is this monstrous chain of Command, as strongly managed as is Cromer’s “harmonious working,” Orientalism can also express the strength of the West and the Orient’s weakness- as seen by West. Such strength and such weakness are as intrinsic to Orientalism as they are to any view that divides the world into large. General divisions, entities that Coexist in a state of tension produced by what is believed to be radical difference.

                            For that is the main intellectual issue raised by Orientalism. Can one divide human reality, seems to be genuinely divide, into clearly different cultures, histories, traditions, societies, even races, and survive the Consequences humanly ? By surviving the Consequences humanly, I mean to ask whether there is any way of avoiding the hostility expressed by the division, say, of men into “us “(westerners) and “they” (Orientals).

Glidden Continues, now more enthusiastically:

                                “It is a notable fact that while the Arab value system demands absolute solidarity within the group, it at the same time encourages among its members a kind of rivalry that is destructive of that very solidarity” ; in Arab society only “ Success counts” and “the end justifies the means”;

                                 Arabs live “naturally” in a world “characterized by anxiety, expressed in generalized suspicion and distrust, which has been labeled free- floating hostility;

                                “The art of subterfuge is highly developed in Arab life, as well as in Islam itself”:

                                 The Arab need for vengeance overrides everything, otherwise the Arab would feel “ ego-destroying “ shame. The purpose of this learned disquisition is merely to show how on the western and Oriental scale of values,

“The relative position of the elements is quite difference.” QED.

Conclusion:
                            
                        This is the apogee of Orientalist Confidence. No merely asserted generality is denied the dignity of truth; no theoretical list of Oriental attributes is without application to the behavior of Orientals in the real world. On the one hand there are westerns, and on the other there are Arab- Orientals; the former are rational, peaceful, liberal, logical, capable of holding real values, without natural suspicion; the latter are none of these things.



Teaching English as Second Language in India,Ec 304,ELT



Name              -     Bhatt. Dhara. J 

Roll no:          -      02

M.A.Part-2    -      Sem-3

Paper               -    04, Ec-304

Paper name    -      ELT-             
"English Teaching Language" 

Topic for Assignment      -

“Teaching English as ‘Second Language’ in India-Kapil Kapoor” 

Submitted To: Mr. Devershi Mehta
  Department of English,
  Bhavnagar university,
  Bhavnagar.                






* Abstract:


                        This paper argues that the concept of English as a second language is not a purely pedagogic construct and has to be properly understood in the larger historical, social and education context. The concept is designed to give English a Pre-eminent position relative to the Indian language in the educational and, Consequently the Socio-political set up. It has also been employed to the Indian languages in the educational, and Consequently the Sociopolitical set up. It has been employed to discourage the study and learning of classical languages, particularly Sanskrit which has contributed to the rootless ness of the young Indian minds. English as a second language along with other Indian minds. It is then argued that there is a fundamental illegality in treating English as a second language along with other Indian languages, and it is this illegality which accounts for the poor ‘Standards’ of English in spite of the tremendous investment in ELT. The situation can only be reminded by recognizing and refining the role and goals of English as a foreign language and by choosing the right language teaching theories and parties. Else, no amount of methodology and technology would succeed.

Teaching English as ‘Second Language’ in India

* Introduction: ->


The term second language is in two different ways-
(I)English is second language after one or more Indian languages, which are primary and more significantly,
(ii) In School Education, the second language is what is introduced after the primary stage and has a pedagogical as well as a functional definition, particularly in the context of the ‘three-language formula’.
                   The significance of English as Second language can only be understood in the larger and in the historical perspective. It is to be noted that English in India is a symbol of linguistic Centolalism whereas the numerous Indian language are seen to represent linguistic regionalism from Macaulay to Murayama Singh, we have seen now in Indian the movement from one to the other. Following the withdrawal of the British from India, the language question naturally came to the fare, in which the central issue was the role and status to English vis-à-vis Indian language, both were vernacular and classical. This Conceptual structure has three parts:
          1 Modernization
          2 Mythologies
          3 Language Policies

1)  Modernization :-> 


              First, the concepts of modernization and internationalism were invoked and English became the language of both modernization and internationalism and by implication the Indian languages became associated with’ tradition’ which by definition was assumed to be anti-modern and backward looking.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                             
2)   Mythology :->


              Once this was taken to be true, the next step in the argument was to define the role and relationship of English vis-à-vis the Indian languages. This need gave birth to ‘language-planning’ which was in fact the linguistic analogue of a particular politics.’ Language planning’ operated with a whole set of lexical weaponry that gradually created a new mythology. Major Indian languages become in this discipline,’ Regional Languages’-and even Hindi is a regional language which has been accorded the status of an official language of the Union and some status.

3) Language Policy :->

            English, the other official language did not suffer from this disability. Its major strength is argued to be the fact that is cannot be identified with anyone region and therefore, English is one pan-Indian’ language that would promote National Integration, as regional would. So while the Indian languages, as regional languages, English a ‘foreign’ language, promote unity and integration. Centralism has an inherent appeal for the intellectuals at a time when an impatient unitary centralism was the dominant political ideology.
          To further buttress this argument, a whole mythology got built up around the role of English in which the central metaphor is the metaphor of the’ window’:

1) English is the language of knowledge (science and technology),
2) English is the language of liberal, modern thinking;
3) English is our window on the world;
4) English is the link language;
5) English is the library language; English is the language of reason;
6) English is the lingua-franca.

          The Education Commission, 1964-66 has this to say about the teaching of English (a Paraphrase): Because for years to come English will continue to be necessary in higher education as a library language, so a solid foundation in English must be laid at the School Stage. We have recommended that study must begins from class V, though we feel that for many students, particularly those in the rural areas, it cannot begin before class VIII. English for a very large number of students will remain only the second or the third language…..

          The elite-mass-rural divide, are projected in this report itself and the indecisiveness about English L2 or L3 is also so much evident. What is L2? What is L3? And what is the first language? These terms get different definitions depending on how they are defined chronologically, linguistically, from the point of view of language policy or pedagogically.
1)   The First Language broadly is the language introduced in the School as a subject from grade I to X and it is commonly used as the medium of instruction at the school level and as the medium of expression by the Lerner in his social Communication. It is usually the mother-tongue or the regional language of the child.

2)   The Second Language, i-e, L2 is that language which is introduced compulsorily either of the end of primary stage or in the beginning of the lower secondary stage after the attainment of sufficient proficiency in the first language by the learner. The main objective of the second language is to enable the speaker for wider participation in society, and the nation leading to Secondary socialization.

3)   The Third Language: L3 is introduced simultaneously or after the initiation of second language. Generally in grade VIII.The main objective of introducing the third language is to prepare the learner for all-India mobility leading to ternary socialization and give the learner  a working knowledge of the language so that the learner may read, comprehend and express correctly in that language.

4)   Notice that as defined above, English functionally, is L3; the third language-it cannot be L2.But English is allowed to be introduced and studies as the second language.

5)   Here is how the report of the working Group on the study of Language (NCERT, 1986) presents the chronological distribution of the three languages, through the school system in the context of the three language formula:








1) Primary Stage :->
           Only Mother Tongue /Regional Language both subject and media from class I to V.

2) Post Primary /Secondary :->
           English and modern Indian language. Three languages to be taught-state language, one modern Indian language and English.

3) Secondary Stage :-> The same pattern as in post primary.

4) Senior Secondary :->
                                    State language and optionally, English for specific purposes.

The picture is like this,
      Stage                                        Class                            Language
1) Lower primary                         I to V                             Mother tongue/state language.

2) Upper Primary                        VI to VIII                       State language/modern Indian                                                                                                                               language English.

3) Secondary                                 IX to X                         State language/modern Indian
Language English.

4) Senior Secondary XI to XII state language C+ ESP, Optical:
                                   
                                   Notice, the relative’ Constancy’ of English: also how to the concept of ‘Second language’ became diffuse. The same report: says this role of English.

                                   “Knowledge is growing at a breath taking pace. English should primarily be taught so that at the end of a four /five year.

(a) It can be used as a library language to enable the learner to keep abreast of the latest accretions to the different fields of knowledge, and.

(b) It can enable the learner to pursue higher/Professional education.

                                    The basic Competencies in the four years should be that of reading, writing, listening and speaking (and) these should be developed with reference to a specific corpus of language material and communication needs.”

                                    This is early recognition of the purely ancillary role of English. Elsewhere, however, English is treated at par with Hindi as a second language, and this is evident: from the ’Constancy’ of English in School stages.

                                    “The three language formula should be effectively implemented. The first language should be the mother tongue/regional language. The second language may be Hindi or English in case of a non Hindi speaking state and one of the modern Indian languages or English in the Hindi speaking states. The third language in non Hindi speaking states should be Hindi or English whichever have not been studies as a second language. Similarly, in the Hindi speaking state, the third language should be English or modern Indian language whichever has not been taught as a second language.”










                                  The provision in effect has made English the second language pedagogically and chronologically all over the country. What is the function of a second language? One NCERT report on Teaching of Hindi as a second language says that
                                 “The purpose on Teaching of Hindi as a second language in relation to the first (language) may be as follows:

1) To help the individual in maintaining his personal relations with the people beyond his linguistic.
2) To help the individual to carry on his business purposes beyond linguistic group.
3) To help the individual to carry on his social and cultural activities beyond his linguistic group
4) To help the individual to feel his identities with a large group, may be the nation.”

                                  In this perspective while Hindi is truly a second language functionally English is certainly not-no Indian uses English for the purposes set but above.

                                  The competence that is required to be attained in a second language, if it is to serve it purpose of secondary socialization, end its’ national and cultural purposes, ’It just a note less than the competence in the first language. Such level of competence obtusely unattainable in a foreign language.

                                  Finally, a review of the problem that has been faced and formulated in the teaching of English as a second language, will exemplify and reinforce what we have said above: lack of clarify about basic concepts, wide gap between facts of the situation, and the assumptions of the recommendation made to improve English.
Teaching, shifting theoretical inputs, wide disparity of practices in different parts of the country, and lack of agreement about the desirable principles and methods are some of major problems that the English teaching has faced all along First, there has been little agreement in attitudes to language –learning, on question such as.

I)  Extent and use of language drills.
ii)  The use of simplified texts or specifically prepared texts or specially compiled texts.
iii)  Amount and range of required reading to be prescribed
iv) Role of grammar in language learning and whether grammar should be at all taught, and lastly.
v) The error-approach the whole philosophy of ‘errors’ and teaching as essentially a re-medical process.

                                 There is also considerable confusion about instructional objectives. Basically it is difficult really to distinguish clearly the differing levels of for the first language and second language, uniformly. That is, the expected levels of attainment in the case of an Indian second language and English as second language cannot be the same.

*        Again, even for English, one can order the skills in different orders of priority! Should it be ‘listening – reading – speaking – writing or ‘reading – listening – speaking? Even when the efforts have been made to delimit the second language objective, one is not convinced by the recommendation, because the reasoning behind them it is not very clear. Also, sometimes the discrete categories get up are not really discrete language. Consider for example the competence in comprehension.
Three levels of competence may be distinguished:

a) Gathering only information about the facts.

b) Developing crucial understanding of the ideas, the learner comes across when he listens or reads.

c) Creative understanding of ideas and values and their creative interpretation.

          Similarly in expression the three levels of competence :->

a) Communicating information in daily conversation or correspondence
b) Communicating the ideas.
c) Communicating abstract ideas , concepts and value with originality .

Conclusion:-

It is the absence of grammar centered teaching that accounts for so much stress on methodology, ‘Method” and ‘methodology’ are dharma in western tradition it is assumed that it the method is right , the god will be automatically achieved , if the facts are correct , with the right method , we are bound to reach the right conclusion. This assumption has created a widespread concern for selecting and refining the right methods. The classical simplicity and democracy of learning / teaching in which the black board the wooden slate , the ink-pen , the ink pot , and a primer or book were all that was needed , is now perhaps instrievably lost  may be it  is not right to abandon technology , may be technological gadgets have a proper use, but surely a country with a huge body of learners needs to examine all these rather closely for , there is no doubt that just as rituals or karma kanda  killed – before it itself was disastrously killed = the sprite of a whole way of life, the rituals of  language teaching takes the enthusiasm and the intellectual challenge out of language teaching , which is reduced to a mechanical routine and process in which “How” become more important the both “What” and “Why”.



Reference  

·       Brown, G., and G. rule. 1983. Discourse Analysis, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

·       Corded, S.P. 1967. “The Significance of learner’s Errors” IRAL, V14.
…1973, Introducing Applied Linguistics. Harmonds-worth,           Middlesex: Penguin.
     
·       Jain, M.P. 1974. “Errors: Source, cause and Significance”, Journal of the school of Languages, Jawaharlal Nehru University, Monsoon Issue.



·       Leech, G. and Svartvik, J. 1973. A Communicative Grammar of English, London: Longman.

·       Mumby, J. 1978. Communicative Syllabus Design, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.


·       Mussen, P.H.1963. The psychological development of the child, Englewood Cliffs: Prentice Hall.

·       Rivers, W. 1968. Teaching Foreign Language Skills, Chicago: University of Chicago Press.


·       Saunders, P.A. 1967. Introductory English, London: FLBS.

·       Wilkins, D.A. 1976. National Syllabuses, London: Oxford University Press.